How reliant on machines should we let ourself become? E.M. Forster is most famous for period dramas but he also wrote a brilliant Science Fiction short story, ‘The Machine Stops’ about it. It is a story I first read in an English Literature lesson at school, a story that convinced me that English Literature could be really, really interesting!
Written in 1909 decades before the first computers were built never mind the internet, video calls, digital music and streaming, he wrote of a future with all of that, where humans live alone in identical underground rooms across the Earth, never leaving because there is no reason to leave, never meeting others because they can meet each other through the Machine. Everything is at hand at the touch of a button. Everything is provided by the Machine, whether food, water, light, entertainment, education, communication, and even air, …
The story covers themes of whether we should let ourself become disconnected from the physical world or not. Is part of what makes us human our embodiment in that world. He refers to this as “the sin against the body” a theme returned to in the film WALL-E. Disconnected from the world humans decline not only in body but also in spirit.
As the title suggests, the story also explores the problems of becoming over-reliant on technology and of what then happens if the technology is taken away. It is more than this though but the issue of repeatedly accepting “good enough” as a replacement for the fidelity of physical and natural reality. What seems wonderfully novel and cool, convenient or just cheaper may not actually be as good as the original. Human-human interaction that is face-to-face is far richer than we get through a video call, for example, and yet meetings have disappeared rapidly in favour of the latter in the 21st century.
Once we do become reliant on machines to service our every whim, what would happen if those ever more connected machines break? Written over a century ago, this is very topical now, of course, as, with our ever increasing reliance on inter-connected digital technology for energy, communication, transport, banking and more, we have started to see outages happen. These have arisen from the consequences of bugs and cyber attacks, from ‘human error’ and technology that it turns out is just not quite dependable enough, leading to country and world-wide outages of the things that constitutes modern living.
How we use technology is up to us all of course, and like magpies we love shiny new toys, but losing all the skills and understanding just because they can be now done by the machine may not be very wise in the long term. More generally, we need to make sure the technology we do make ourselves reliant on, is really, really dependable: far more dependable than our current standards are in actual practice. That needs money and time, not rushed introductions, but also more Computer Science research on how to do dependability better in practice. Above all we need to make sure we do continue to understand the systems we build well enough to maintain them in the long term.
Paul Curzon, Queen Mary University of London
More on …
Subscribe to be notified whenever we publish a new post to the CS4FN blog.
This page is funded by EPSRC on research agreement EP/W033615/1.
cs4fn 