by Paul Curzon, Queen Mary University of London
How much should we change the world to make it easier for our machines to work?
Plant scientists have spotted a problem they can solve. Weeding robots are finding it difficult to weed. It is a hard problem for them. All those weeds look just like the real crop which they aren’t supposed to destroy. So the robots are pulling up the wrong things. What is a robot to do? Should we make it easy for them?
Plant Scientists have seen a need for their technology which is looking for solutions any where it can. Robots are good at distinguishing colour. That is easy. So why not just genetically modify weeds to be blue. This is possible as there are already lots of genes causing blueness in plants (think blueberries). Problem solved. The robots then won’t get it wrong again and the crops are safe.
What could possibly go wrong? Well, to work the genes will need to be spread wildly and perhaps they could escape and get into our crops or other plants that are just there to be plants, or just plants in the food chain, We could end up with a blue planet a bit like the red one the martians brought int he War of the Worlds. Alternatively, evolution might step up and continually produce mutant weeds that subverted that gene, given that gene killed them. Perhaps all the problems can guarantee to be avoided, though the wise person does not bet against natural selection finding a way round problems presented to it in the long term.
Isn’t it time we learnt our lesson and stopped changing the planet to make our machines lives easier? Of course we have been doing that for a long time – think of all the roads scarring the countryside so cars work or rails so trains work. Perhaps we should think more about the needs of the planet as well as of people, rather than the needs of our machines when innovating, especially when undoubtedly eventually (if we don’t destroy ourselves first) we will have machines clever enough to work it out.
There are always lots of ways of solving problems and it is important to think about the planet now not just our machines. Perhaps robots should just not weed until they can do it without us having to change the problem (and the planet) for them so they can!
More on …
Magazines and booklets …
Our Books …
- The Power of Computational Thinking:
- Games Magic and Puzzles to help you become a computational thinker
- Conjuring with Computation
- Learn the basics of computer science through magic tricks
Subscribe to be notified whenever we publish a new post to the CS4FN blog.
This blog is funded through EPSRC grant EP/W033615/1.
cs4fn 